platoon why did barnes kill elias

Like everybody else. Chris is thematically focused on understanding how to apply what he knows. User Reviews Three or four squads make up a platoon, which has 20 to 50 soldiers and is commanded by a lieutenant. In the heat of hand to hand combat, Sgt. Given the United States track record and reputation for military dominance throughout the world, the Vietnam conflict is a confusing time. Barnes has become a ruthless, cold-blooded killer. The smell was chemical and horrific. CHRIS: I was wrong. I know he did. Would this movie be considered "un-American?". Barnes leadership, committing war crimes against the villagers. Captain. Barnes holds no value for civilian life in Vietnam and almost seems to value Sgt. BARNES: What the hells matter with you Taylor! The scar-faced Barnes is a brave and utterly ruthless killing machine. RHAH: I remember you first came in here Taylor. Ironically, it is the impact of Sgt. Once again, Stone emphasizes power dynamics and character motivations, as some soldiers fight bravely while others reveal their true colors and hide, such asSergeant Red O'Neill (John C. McGinley). There are many illustrations of Chris doing throughout the film, however, the sequence where he and his platoon ravage a Vietnamese village illustrates Chris engaging in activities contrary to his essential nature. (Stone, p.85). From there, the narration becomes more complex and gives a deeper meaning to Platoon: "There are times since, I've felt like the child born of those two fathers. I shit you not! Barnes and Sgt. Out here assholes, ya keep your shit wired tight at all times! Platoon Barnes was in co-command of 2nd Platoon along with Sgt. This provokes Chris to attack Barnes, signifying that Chris does stand for something, and he honors the beliefs and ideals that Elias stood for. What is not appreciated also illustrates the forewarning. Barnes is killed by Taylor in the end, where Taylor does a typical "Barnes" move by killing those he is supposed to stand strongest with. (to Chris) And that goes for you, shit for brains. Lias, he was full of shit, Lias was a crusader - I got no fight with a man does what hes told, but when he dont, the machine breaks down, and when the machine breaks down, we break down and I aint gonna allow that. Why did Elias smile at Barnes? Remember what it looks like. But they saw a bloodied Sgt. Therefore they would probably have to break in new recruits, until the WIA's were fit for duty again. Even though Lieutenant Wolfe is the highest ranking officer in the platoon, he is young, inexperienced, and has only recently come to Vietnam. Far from it, as Audie Murphy was awarded the Medal Of Honor and every other medal for bravery in combat, sometimes in multiples. Maybe Ive finally found it, way down here in the mud. When Sgt. Why did Elias smile at Barnes? Platoon is a 1986 film about a young recruit in Vietnam who faces a moral crisis when confronted with the horrors of war and the duality of man. Essential Equipment for Your Landscaping Business. Immediately experiencing platoon life in Vietnam abruptly begins to change the naive, idyllic notions Chris, a volunteer, has about war. Hispanic kid seen praying when Wolfe goes into bunker where Barnes and others are playing poker. Who leads a platoon in the Army? BARNES: Elias - you take your squad and Ill take Tex and Francis from your squad. He uses this theory to try to convince others in the platoon that Sgt. CHRIS: Not just me its the way the whole thing works. Before, Barnes looked Elias in the eye and shot him. KING: You what? The inhumane, merciless treatment Barnes carries out shocks Chris and rekindles his conscience and sense of morals. Barnes finds Elias alone and shoots him, then returns and tells Chris that Elias was killed by the enemy. The gesture of reaching towards the heavens, thats not something we talked about. After the aerial bombardment, he wakes up from a state of unconsciousness, picks up an enemy rifle, and aims it at Barnes. Not one. These lines obviously reference the internal conflict amongst his unit, and Taylor statesthat the Vietnam War will always be with him. The FAQ items below may give away important plot points. The American military is in Vietnam attempting to defeat the Viet Cong and prevent the spread of communism, which creates a state of war within this country. Everybody knows whos really in charge of the platoon. Elias takes Chrisand two other men to intercept flanking enemy troops. Company. Whenever he gets involved with what he feels is the reason for a situation being a certain way (the cause), it really gets under his skin. Why did Sgt Barnes shoots Elias? There's a similar scene in Full Metal Jacket (1987) where a toy rabbit is used as a booby trap. You fuck up in a fire fight and I goddamn guarantee you a trip out of the bush, in a body bag! CRAWFORD: Sounds like it. When Barnes suspects the villagers of being Viet Cong sympathizers, Barnes viciously shoots and kills the wife of the village chief, and threatens to shoot the chiefs young daughter as a means of coercing information out of the chief about the Viet Cong. CHRIS: Yever get caught in a mistake King and you just cant get out of it? But in actuality, he doesn't know for sure that Sgt. But, be that as it may, those of us who did make it have an obligation to build again, to teach to others what we know, and to try with what's left of our lives to find a goodness and meaning to this life.". Barnes as the leading commander in the platoon instead of the inexperienced Lt. Wolfe; he doesnt do anything when Barnes and others in the platoon commit war crimes against the Vietnamese villagers; he also doesnt realize that the platoon is about to be caught in a crossfire trap by the Viet Cong. Barnes conceives of killing Chris as a means of eliminating anyone whos a threat of implicating him in the murder of Elias. Sgt. On the final patrol Chris flips into heroism or psychosis, wipes out a nest of North Vietnamese and confronts the demon he has almost become. Elias warns Barnes that he shouldnt send the new men in the platoon out on an all night ambush because they would most likely engage the enemy, and their inexperience would make them inadequate for the patrol. Barnes shoots a woman in the head in front of her husband, and then threatens to shoot the mans young daughter if he doesnt give Barnes information about the Viet Cong. The platoon commits war crimes against the village as a means of releasing frustration for the deaths of the members in their platoon. Barnes orders the rest of the platoon to retreat, and goes back into the jungle to find Elias' group. The others in the platoon view the experienced Sgt. It's possible Francis' tour was close to being over. Hes seen a lot of action in his day and has already served several tours in Vietnam. Edit, No, it's anti-war. You got no proof man. When Barnes is faced with an accusation, or when he can directly accuse someone else for being the cause of a problem, he really gets upset and motivated. Barnes focuses on Chris preconscious responses as being the cause of the problem. Sgt. ): Day by day, I struggle to maintain not only my strength, but my sanity. Next:Platoon True Story: How Accurate Is The Vietnam War Movie. This also means it has been incorporated into the Dramatica Story Expert application itself as an easily referenced contextual example. There are so many war movies out there to choose from, yet not many come from the perspectiveof a man who personally lived through the hell that was the Vietnam War. Hundreds of dead American and Viet Cong soldiers bodies are strewn all about the compound and nearby jungle floor. RHAH: (puffing on his bowl) How do you know the dinks didnt get him. When you know you know. He doesn't kill any civilians during the raid on Barnes crosses that line. There's nature and technology, free will and fate - that place had changed him and in killing Barnes, he acknowledges as much, if only to break the spell. He relies on his knowledge of war to react and perform quickly. Promoted to 1st Squad's Sergeant at end of film.Pvt Huffmeister (Survives): Seen standing behind O'Neil when he is given command of the platoon. This frustration is derived from past events the platoon has recently suffered, such as the loss of two men in the all night ambush, the loss of two additional men in a booby trapped Viet Cong bunker, and the abduction of another platoon member who is found strapped to a tree, dead and mutilated. Elas Character Analysis. Edit, Yes, and it's probably a composite of several of them. RHAH: (puffing on his bowl) How do you know the dinks didnt get him. He was also the Technical Advisor for the film. Barnes RTO.Doc (KIA): Also shot while defending CP bunker, he is still rolling around after being shot but would appear to have died from his wounds as he is not seen at the end with the other survivors (this is also the case in the script). Get that other cherry up here, Gardner! While the platoon is extracting via helicopter, they see a mortally wounded Elias emerge from the treeline being chased by NVA soldiers, who eventually kill him. He was in an area by himself, armed with a walkie-talkie from which he got instructions from Oliver Stone. When Taylor discovers Barnes in Platoon, both men aren't doing well after the NVA attack and the subsequent air raid. The light of the moon. In one scene, Barnes is bathed in red light, symbolizing the evil within. Sgt. Did he try to kill himself? Barnes would have been court-martialled, the civil war in the platoon would have subsided, and Barnes wouldnt have been able to ultimately kill Elias. Edit, Yes, it was likely meant as an ironic statement by the tank crew. If the U.S. military would have proven to be a more effective adversary in the jungle style warfare waged against the Viet Cong, the U.S. would have probably won the war; If Lt. Wolfe had been a proven combat soldier, many situations the platoon faced wouldnt have resulted with such ill consequences; If Sgt. Taylor's message is that Vietnam should become a message, a morality tale for those who come afterward, and a reminder that the world should never fall so far. CHRIS: Yever get caught in a mistake King and you just cant get out of it? Why does Chris Taylor (Charlie Sheen) call Barnes and Elias his "fathers" during the final monologue. He is a naive and overly idealistic infantry enlistee that has dropped out of school and joined the war in order to gain a sense of pride about himself; to do his share for the U.S., and to become anonymous like the rest of the men in his platoon. Chris views the division in the platoon as a direct result of Barnes lack of respect for human life and unscrupulous morals: I'm sure most of us has seen the Oliver Stone Vietnam flick Platoon, so my question is. (Stone, p. 21). Thematically, the final war sequence is designed to parallel the Elias shooting scene. 2nd Squad (Bravo): squad leader.Pvt Flash (KIA) Killed by NVA soldier, seen lying dead next to Sgt. While the platoon is being extracted via helicopter, they glimpse Elias, mortally wounded, emerging from the treeline and being chased by a group of North Vietnamese soldiers, who kill him. That day we loved him(Stone, p. 45) Since not all the squibs exploded as planned, Dafoe ended up throwing the detonator to the side during the take that made the final cut. Its all a blur. The day after suffering its most severe casualties, the platoon and several companies are sent right back into the same enemy-saturated area. He aint gonna bite you. Live up to what Grandpa did in the First War and Dad the Second. Barnes would have brought Chris down to his level of evil and would have officially corrupted his soul which means he still would have won.3) Barnes wasn't evil. Whereas, for Sgt. He's the guy with the M79 who brings the village elder to Barnes to interrogate. Elias decision to report Barnes criminal conduct at the village precipitates a rift between the members in the platoon (some siding with Barnes and others siding with Elias), and ultimately causes Barnes to kill Elias. Elias murder, Chris tries to convince some of the others in the platoon that they need to kill Barnes in revenge. The consequence of not making progress in the war is the men will have to keep fighting, subjected to the inhumane preconscious responses they have developed in order to stay alive. Posted: 7/31/2021 2:23:23 PM EST. ACE: they caught em last night trying to pull some shit on Charlie Company. These past events, in conjunction with having to survive in horrific living conditions and being immersed in a constant state of fear, drive the platoon into a My-Lai-esque frenzy that results in the destruction of the village.

Lucky Direction For Kanya Rashi, Josephine Violet Barbee, Michael Kostka Obituary, Cadbury's Caramel Bunny Miriam Margolyes, Lana Condor Mary Condor, Harlem Shuffle Ending Explained, Ck3 Roman Culture Event, Juegos De Carreras De Patos En El Agua, Heinrich Harrer Spouse,